Is Modular Design and Construction Right for Higher Education Projects?

Bergmeyer Principal Darryl Filippi shares why modular design and construction is an excellent option for higher education facilities.
2021 12 6modulardesign endicott

Originally published in American School and University's 2021 Architectural Portfolio, Darryl Filippi explains the benefits of choosing the modular design and construction route.

Is modular design and construction right for higher education projects?

As architects, we aim to find the right solution for unique problems. When our client at Endicott College found the school was short on beds for student enrollment, they immediately reached out to Bergmeyer to ask how a 300- bed residence hall could be designed and built in less than 14 months. We knew the response “it’s not possible” was not an option. Working with our building partner, Windover Construction, we quickly realized that building through volumetric modular construction was the only option.

The great debate I’ve heard against modular construction is that it doesn’t live up to the durability requirements of higher education facilities. While the most significant benefit of modular construction is an accelerated project completion schedule, it doesn’t mean that quality has to suffer.

The modular construction industry thrives on building within a controlled environment. By eliminating the influences of weather and site logistics, quality consistency can be achieved through a well-managed workforce and refined detailing.

Even with a high level of quality control, continuous and thoughtful engagement throughout the modular fabrication design and construction process is still a necessity for design/builders. Fabrication must consider the rigors of travel so material selection and construction are inherently part of the process, reinforcing the commitment to a very durable end-product.

Modular Design and Construction Standish Hall at Endicott College

Can modular construction be delivered for less cost?

While material costs are driven by the market, modular construction is almost always more advantageous due to benefits from its fabrication efficiency, reduced labor costs, and delivering the site to completion faster than traditional stick-built projects. However, as we face today’s supply chain challenges, an additional benefit we’re finding is the buying power of established fabricators allows them to order and manage the material supplies as one streamlined source.

For example, our project with Endicott College's Standish Hall allowed us to construct 128 modular units (typically 12 feet wide by 52 feet long), including kitchens, bathrooms, windows, mechanical, electrical, and fire protection. There’s a tremendous advantage to negotiating price when dealing with that level of product being delivered to one plant.

It’s imperative that the architect, contractor, and fabricator collaborate on managing the design and construction to maximize the efficiency and delivery of the product and to ensure that it’s delivered in a timely manner to reduce on-site construction.

Our team at Bergmeyer is integrating technology through Building Information Modeling (BIM), which speeds up coordination and fabrication while reducing conflicts which can save on costly changes that typically arise during on-site construction.

This translates to less on-site construction on occupied campuses, contributing to better campus safety and fewer negative impacts to campus life.

Modular Design and Construction NY Residence Hall

Does modular design limit creativity?

Residence halls are a fantastic candidate for modular construction due to the repetitive nature of the program. While modular construction has historically prioritized repetition and efficiency over aesthetics, there have been significant advancements to the ‘look’ of modular buildings in recent years, particularly when a skilled designer partners with an experienced contractor and knowledgeable fabricator; the only limit we have with modular construction is our own creativity.

There are strategic design moves we need to be aware of for internal planning in relation to constructability, but the exterior envelope is flexible in relation to massing, materials, natural light, ventilation, and of course, budget.

I find not only are all the components of fabricating “the box” important with their infrastructure and interior components, but the same strategic thinking must also be considered for the exterior materials and windows. In my mind, the more that can be completed within the factory versus on-site, the faster the project is delivered.

Our recent design for Endicott College’s Standish Hall limited the use of masonry but incorporated large cement fiber panels so surface areas could be covered quickly. In contrast, on a current project being developed in Albany, NY, our design optimizes windows, so the surface areas that will be installed in the field are basically metal panels that cover the joints between the modules. Two different facades are achieved using basic modular components.

When it comes to the quality of the interior spaces, again, there is no limit. Functional, warm, engaging environments can stand the test of time and rival to any traditional stick-built environments.

Modular buildings achieve higher STC (sound transmission coefficient) due to double walls and floors/ceilings, thereby doubling insulating control. Nowhere does acoustical performance contribute to students’ health and wellness than in where they live and sleep.

While modular design/construction is a slam dunk for residence halls, we are also eager to adapt it to other project types. With our Windover Construction partners, Bergmeyer has also conceptualized on a nursing teaching center at another New England campus.

Understanding the nuances of volumetric modular fabrication allows us to think beyond the program and concentrate on delivering functional and beloved projects to campuses in a timely manner, regardless of market conditions.

Modular Design and Construction Standish Hall at Endicott College Dorm
Modular Design and Construction
Modular Design and Construction Standish Hall at Endicott College Exterior Dorms
Modular Design and Construction Standish Hall at Endicott College Dorm
Modular Design and Construction

Scroll through the images of Endicott College’s Standish Hall from construction to completion.

Trending now

Tik Tok Gen Z web
How Gen Z and TikTok Created a Consumer Revolution
One of the most prominent present-day marketing challenges a business can face is capturing a target audience’s attention and keeping them intrigued for the long haul.
Hampshire Web Thumb
Enduring Design: Hampshire Dining Commons Turns Ten
We asked the UMass Amherst Dining Services team to share their thoughts, feedback, and statistics on the modern-day Hampshire Dining Commons.
Join us for the Upcoming Career Paths through PAVE Event in Boston
Help us grow the future of retail at Career Paths through PAVE.
HHAC 2023 Scholarship
The 2023 Hip Hop Architecture Camp x Bergmeyer Scholarship + Internship Program
We are excited to announce that the application window for the 2023 Hip Hop Architecture Camp x Bergmeyer Scholarship and Internship Program is now open!
Sociasl2 05
The Romance of Tangibility
In light of the recent movement for “vintage” innovation, Bergmeyer Graphic Designer Ariana Piacquadio reflects on the romanticization of the analog world. As the tables are rapidly turning backward with tech so commonplace, real-life experiences you can engage with using all your senses start to embody a new kind of nuance and exclusivity.
2022 CD Retails New Horizon
Retail's New Horizon
How can retail brands seize the moment and reinvent themselves?
2022 Behind the Bar Web
Behind the Bar
Operational efficiency is critical to ensuring a seamless experience in the hospitality industry. Our design team decided to get "behind the bar" with several sought-after libation destinations serving Boston's Seaport community to get a design perspective from the people integral to facilitating world-class restaurant experiences.
2022 SDAT Petaluma Web Full
Reimagining Petaluma’s Community as a 15-Minute City
The passionate locals of Petaluma called upon us to help them achieve their goal of becoming a more accessible “15-minute city,” where every resident can access most of their daily necessities within a 15-minute walk or bike ride.
2022 CK Meta Web
Connecting with Customers in Virtual Retail Experiences
How will shopping in the Metaverse compare with real-life experiences?
Promotions 2022 2023
Bergmeyer Announces 2022 Leadership and Practice Promotions
As we look forward to the New Year, we are celebrating the many achievements and successes of our team.
2022 Bthe Change Web
B the Change - A Commitment to Giving Forward
A new social responsibility mission statement that reinforces giving forward as a core part of our design collaborative.
2022 Quinn Metaverse Web
The Responsibility of Designers in a Virtual World
Although the Metaverse is still in its infancy, designers should be prepared to play a significant role in the next digital revolution.
2023 PAVE Scholarship web
The 2023 Bergmeyer x PAVE Scholarship and Mentorship Experience
Submit for the 2023 Bergmeyer x PAVE Scholarship and Mentorship Experience by January 13, 2023!
Metaverse Web
Designing the Future: The Meta-Dilemma on the Role of Designers in a Virtual World
Four designers share their unique perspectives on what we may experience in the Metaverse and task the design industry with being ready to create for both the physical and the virtual world.
The Pan-Mass Challenge 2022: Trusting Your Instincts and the Importance of Self-Advocacy
Team Bergmeyer recently rode in the 2022 Pan-Mass Challenge, which raises funds for cancer research and treatment at Dana-Farber Cancer Institute.
Artboard 3
Design Outside the Lines
Built environments can guide our thoughts, behavior, and habits. So, in a world that is rapidly changing, why do many of the spaces we use every day remain the same? Bergmeyer Interior Designer Eliza Steele shares her thoughts on designing outside the lines.
Shutterstock 117585706
Designing Out Waste
Building waste accounts for a staggering 35-40% of worldwide waste in landfills, and carbon emissions from both building erection and deconstruction are increasing. These factors can be daunting when considering whether the design profession is an active or passive player- in the unending game we play each day with environmental management.
So-Ho Inspired: Design Trends in NYC
Our retail design team fueled our creativity and reinforced our desire for true connectivity.
Microsoft Teams image 2
Mike Davis on the role of Director of Corporate Social Responsibility
Transitioning from President to the Director of Corporate Social Responsibility, Mike had the opportunity to re-imagine his role within our Design Collaborative to focus on Bergmeyer's goals of serving the greater public good.
Microsoft Teams image 1
Influential Black Leaders, and their Stories that Inspire Us
Beyond the month dedicated to celebrating Black History are the people and their stories that have made a permanent and influential impact on our lives.